In the realm of online reviews, Trustpilot stands out as a platform that promises transparency and openness. However, the reality for businesses listed on Trustpilot often paints a different picture. What initially seems like an inclusive platform for genuine user reviews can quickly turn into a nightmare, with companies finding themselves at the mercy of Trustpilot’s questionable practices.
Many businesses, like ours, did not actively choose to be on Trustpilot. In 2019, a user left a 5-star review for our company on Trustpilot.com, and suddenly, we were thrust into a situation where we had no control over what others said about us on a public forum. This lack of control over our online presence was just the beginning of our unsettling journey with Trustpilot.
Trustpilot prides itself on being a “free and open” platform, but the stark reality is that businesses are often held hostage, their online reputation subject to the whims of anonymous users. The promise of an open, trusted platform, driven by real user experiences, starts to unravel when faced with the hidden complexities at the heart of Trustpilot.
One of the most troubling aspects is the inability to remove a business profile once it’s added to Trustpilot. Anyone can create a “business profile,” and even if you can verify yourself as a legal representative, you still cannot eliminate your company or information from the platform. This lack of control becomes a serious issue when reviews are not genuine or when relationships with Trustpilot sour, leading to public accusations of abuse.
The “catch 22” situation emerges from Trustpilot’s own terms, dictating that to use their platform, businesses must agree to these terms. However, the consent to be listed on their platform is revoked when a review is submitted without the company’s permission or verification. This creates a scenario where businesses are forced to accept Trustpilot’s terms retroactively, with no option to opt out.
Responding to a review on Trustpilot further complicates matters. To engage with users or address concerns, businesses must register and, in turn, accept Trustpilot’s terms. Whether a company opts for free or paid services, agreeing to these terms becomes a prerequisite, establishing a framework for legal rights and obligations. If a business disagrees with or cannot comply with these terms, Trustpilot essentially becomes an inescapable digital labyrinth.
To underscore the flawed nature of this system, a test was conducted by posting a review for a completely fictitious company. The ease with which a fabricated review could be placed on Trustpilot raises serious concerns about the platform’s credibility. The implications of such a lax verification process become even more alarming when one considers the potential for harm caused by fake reviews targeting local businesses.
The burden then falls on businesses to claim their profile and request Trustpilot to investigate the legitimacy of a review. While theoretically a straightforward process, the reality is far from simple. Trustpilot’s power dynamics become evident as businesses navigate a system where their online reputation is held hostage, subject to the platform’s rules and regulations.
In conclusion, Trustpilot’s claim of being a “free and open” platform is, in reality, a double-edged sword for businesses. The lack of control over their online presence, combined with questionable practices and a binding agreement retroactively enforced, paints a disturbing picture of a platform that falls short of its promises. As businesses grapple with the repercussions of negative reviews and the inability to opt out, Trustpilot’s flaws become glaringly apparent, raising crucial questions about the ethics and transparency of online review platforms
Leave a Reply